The Pacific Exploratory Mission in the Tropical Pacific:
PEM-Tropics A, August-September, 1996
Introduction
During the early part of this decade, NASA through its Earth Sciences
Program initiated the Pacific Exploratory Missions (PEM) to improve
scientific understanding of human influences on the tropospheric chemistry
over the Pacific Ocean. The PEM studies were conducted as part of NASA's
Global Tropospheric Experiment (GTE), and, to date, have consisted of
three airborne campaigns. PEM-West A &
B were conducted over the northwestern Pacific during
September-October 1992 (PEM-West A, Hoell et al., 1996) and
February-March 1994 (PEM-West B, Hoell et al., 1997) to study Asian
outflow during contrasting meteorological conditions. The third,
PEM-Tropics A, was conducted during August -September 1996, and focused on
the southern tropical regions of the Pacific Ocean, extending zonally
across the entire Pacific Basin and meridionally from Hawaii to south of
New Zealand. A fourth campaign, PEM-Tropics
B, is scheduled for March/April 1999. Like PEM-West A & B, the
combined PEM-Tropics A & B campaigns will provide observations during
contrasting seasons (i.e., dry vs. wet). This paper describes the
experimental design of the PEM-Tropics A campaign and summarizes some of
the results given in the companion papers in this issue
One of the most important issues in global tropospheric chemistry is
the sensitivity of the oxidizing power of the troposphere to human
influence. From the perspective of global tropospheric chemistry, the
Pacific basin is a very large chemical reaction vessel. From Peru to
Borneo, it stretches 17,700 km in the east-west direction; the distance
from the Antarctic ice shelf to Alaska is 13,300 km. The Pacific basin
covers 35% of the total surface area of the earth, and 50% of the ocean
surface. Since much of the Pacific basin is far removed from continental
influences, observations in this region can provide sensitive indicators
of the global-scale impact of human activity on the oxidizing power of the
troposphere.
There also is a need to improve our understanding of atmospheric sulfur
chemistry over the Pacific. Sulfate aerosols affect the Earth's radiative
balance through direct back-scattering of solar radiation and indirectly
as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN). CCN, themselves products of aerosol
growth processes, are believed to originate through nucleation processes
involving gas phase H2SO4 that is produced from
the oxidation of SO2 by OH. Sulfate and SO2 over
the Pacific may originate from a number of sources including long-range
transport of anthropogenic pollution, marine biogenic releases of
dimethlysulfide (DMS), and volcanic emissions. The relative contributions
of these sources over different regions of the Pacific are still poorly
known, representing a serious limitation in our ability to evaluate the
role of sulfur in global climate change.
Prior to the PEM campaigns, there was little chemical data for the
southern tropical Pacific region. The GAMETAG aircraft missions in 1977
and 1978 (Davis, 1980) provided some early data over the western part of
the Pacific. However, these campaigns were restricted by the low ceiling
and limited endurance of the aircraft, and also by the instrumentation
available at the time. The more recent STRATOZ III (Drummond et al., 1988)
and PEM-West A & B missions have provided detailed data along the
South American and Asian rims of the Southern Pacific basin, respectively.
Ozonesonde and CO measurements have been made from island sites during the
SEAREX program and from ships. Even so, there were virtually no data for
the southeast quadrant of the Pacific basin extending from the
international dateline to the South American coast. The PEM-Tropics A
observations (and those from the forthcoming PEM-Tropics B campaign)
provide an extensive set of atmospheric measurements in a heretofore data
sparse region. Data from this mission (e.g. airborne chemical
measurements, meteorological and ozonesonde observations, and model
products) along with data from all previous GTE field campaigns, have been
archived in the Langley Distributed Active Archive Center (http://eosweb.larc.nasa.gov)
and/or on the GTE Home Page at http://www-gte.larc.nasa.gov.
Implementation of the PEM-Tropics Campaign
The major objectives of PEM-Tropics (Phases A and B) are to provide
baseline data over the southern Pacific Ocean for gases important in
controlling the oxidizing power of the atmosphere, including O3,
H2O, NO, CO and hydrocarbons, to improve scientific
understanding of the factors controlling the concentrations of these
gases, and to assess the resulting sensitivity of the oxidizing power of
the atmosphere to anthropogenic and natural perturbations. In addition,
PEM-Tropics A had three secondary objectives: (1) to survey the
concentrations of aerosol precursors and ultra- fine aerosol particles
over the Southern Pacific basin; (2) to improve our understanding of
sulfur gas-to-particle formation over the region; and (3) to provide
detailed latitude-altitude transects of long-lived gases for the
evaluation of global tropospheric models.
To address these objectives, NASA, through a competitive process
(Announcement of Opportunity), selected investigators who provided
measurements and/or model analyses during PEM-Tropics A. The PEM-Tropics
Science Team consisted of the Principal Investigator(s) from each
investigative group. The Mission Scientists and Mission Meteorologists,
also competitively selected, led the science team in developing the
detailed design of the PEM-Tropics A campaign. Tables
1a and 1b list the DC-8 and P-3B
aircraft investigations, respectively. Table
2 lists the meteorological and modeling investigations, along with
the Mission Meteorologists and Scientists. The aircraft instrumentation
layout is included in Figures 1a and
1b for the DC-8 and P-3B,
respectively.
The NASA DC-8 aircraft has a nominal ceiling of 12 km, a cruising speed
of 800 km/hr, and, as configured during PEM-Tropics A, a 10 hr flight
endurance. The P-3B aircraft has a nominal ceiling of 8 km, a cruising
speed of 500 km/hr, and, as configured in PEM-Tropics A, a nominal 8 hr
endurance. These differing characteristics, coupled with the instrument
payload of each aircraft, favored use of the DC-8 for long range transport
studies and high altitude observations, and the P-3B for lower altitude,
process-oriented studies. The differential absorption lidar (DIAL) aboard
the DC-8 provided vertical profiles of ozone and aerosol above and below
the aircraft (Browell et al., 1996), thereby enhancing transport studies
conducted by the DC-8. The DIAL profiles provided a two-dimensional
perspective of the structure of the troposphere in which the in
situ measurements aboard the DC-8, and in some cases the P-3B, were
recorded. The DIAL profiles also provided real time guidance for adjusting
the DC-8 flight tracks to exploit interesting measurement opportunities
encountered in-flight.
The P-3B instrument payload included measurements of a unique suite of
sulfur species [DMS, SO2, methane sulfonic acid (MSA) [gas], H2SO4
[gas], non-seasalt sulfate (NSS), and methane sulfonate (MS)], along
with aerosol composition and size distributions, including ultrafine
particles. These measurements, combined with the capability for reliable
observations of OH, via the Chemical Ionization Mass Spectrometry (CIMS)
technique (Eisele and Tanner, 1991), provided a unique opportunity for the
focussed sulfur process studies that were conducted by the P-3B.
The broad design of the PEM-Tropics A campaign employed a series of
flights from remote operational sites in the south Pacific basin.
Figures 2a and
2b shows these sites, along with flight
tracks of the DC-8 (fig 2a.) and the P-3B (fig. 2b) aircraft. The flight
numbers in Figure 2 are keyed to Table 3a
and 3b in which the major focus of
each flight is summarized. As part of the overall design of PEM-Tropics,
measurements obtained from the NASA DC-8 and P-3B during the intensive
deployment period were augmented by ozonesonde observations from
operational launch sites at Easter Island, and Lauder, New Zealand (also
shown in figure 2), and by stations established by the GTE Project at
Papeete, Tahiti and American Samoa. Figure 2 also shows the ozonesonde
release site on Fiji which was established by the GTE project in August
1997 to support the PEM-Tropics B
mission. Ozonesondes at all the sites, except Fiji, were released at a
rate of one per week, beginning in August 1995, approximately one year
prior to the aircraft campaign in 1996. Releases at all sites are
scheduled to continue through October 1999, to encompass the upcoming
PEM-Tropics B mission, and a final survey of the dry season period. During
the aircraft deployment periods, the sites established by GTE and the
Lauder station increased their launch rate to 2 per week. It is
anticipated that the
ozonesonde data from Fiji and Samoa will provide an indicator of the
seasonal changes in the gradients of trace gases that were observed to
exist across the SPCZ during PEM-Tropics A (Gregory et al., this issue).
Meteorological support for real-time flight planning and post-mission
analyses to assist in coupling air mass transport and chemistry is a
critical element of GTE field campaigns. Meteorological support for
in-field flight planning during PEM-Tropics A was provided by a Mission
Meteorologist stationed with each aircraft, with supporting activities at
the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and Florida State
University (FSU). Meteo France also provided significant support by
allowing direct access to ECMWF gridded data and by providing valuable
consultations at their Papeete, Tahiti facilities. Satellite images
received and stored at MIT, along with derived products from FSU and MIT
(i.e., streamline and trajectory analyses at various pressure levels,
potential vorticity, etc.), were transmitted to the field operations sites
at Christmas Island and Easter Island using a portable high-speed
satellite-telephone data link. For operations at Christmas Island, and to
a lesser extent at Easter Island, this data link provided the only access
to meteorological data. A combination of the satellite data link, faxed
data products, and the use of local meteorological facilities were used
during operations at Papeete, Tahiti, Christchurch, New Zealand, Nadi,
Fiji and Guayaquil, Ecuador.
Integration of instruments aboard the P-3B and DC-8 aircraft occurred,
respectively, at the NASA Wallops Flight Facility, Wallops Island, VA, and
the NASA Ames Research Center (ARC), Moffett Field, CA. The P-3B deployed
approximately one week prior to the DC-8's departure, with transit flights
to Christmas Island via ARC and Hawaii (see Table 3b). The original flight
plans called for two local P-3B flights at Christmas Island; however, the
P-3B experienced aircraft problems after the first local flight, and
returned to Hawaii for repairs. After completing integration and test
flights, the DC-8 departed ARC for Tahiti via Hawaii. The DC-8 and P-3B
arrived in Tahiti on the same day. During this transit flight to Tahiti,
both aircraft conducted substantial vertical profiling to document
inter-hemispheric gradients of gases, along with a coordinated low
altitude fly-by of Christmas Island to document concentrations of several
key constituents measured several days earlier during the P-3B's local
flight from Christmas Island.
Flight operations from Tahiti included three local flights by each
aircraft, followed by transit flights by both the DC-8 and the P-3B to
Easter Island. Each aircraft conducted two local flights from Easter
Island after which the P-3B traveled to Guayaquil, Ecuador, and the DC-8
to Christchurch, New Zealand, with a stop over and local flight from
Tahiti. While the DC-8 operated out of New Zealand, the P-3B conducted
three local flights from Guayaquil to examine inter-hemispheric exchange
and the primary productivity rich oceanic region near the equator prior to
returning to the NASA Wallops Flight Facility. The DC-8's local flight out
of Christchurch extended south to the Antarctic coast to investigate
meridional gradients and the influence of transport from high latitudes on
the tropical troposphere. From Christchurch the DC-8 flew to Fiji, where
three local flights were conducted, followed by the return flight to ARC
via Tahiti.
Overview of PEM Tropics Results
This section provides a brief synopsis of the salient results from
PEM-Tropics A that are discussed in detail in the companion papers of this
issue. Among its accomplishments, the PEM-Tropics A field campaign has
provided a unique set of atmospheric measurements in a heretofore data
sparse region; demonstrated the capability of several new or improved
instruments for measuring OH, H2SO4, NO, and NO2,
and actinic fluxes; and conducted experiments which tested our
understanding of HOx and NOx photochemistry, as
well as for sulfur oxidation and aerosol formation processes. In addition,
PEM-Tropics A documented for the first time the considerable and
widespread influence of biomass burning pollution over the South Pacific,
and identified the South Pacific Convergence Zone (SPCZ) as a major
barrier for atmospheric transport in the southern hemisphere.
New/Improved Measurements:
The DC-8 instrument payload included a new generation
photo-fragmentation two-photon laser-induced fluorescence (PF-TP-LIF)
instrument for measuring NO and NO2 (Sandholm et al., 1997;
Bradshaw, et al., 1998). The improved sensitivity of this instrument
provided, for the first time, accurate NO measurements at sub-pptv
concentrations. Further, a high flow rate sample inlet system was employed
to minimize the possibility that complex nitrogen oxides would decompose
in the inlet system, which had been speculated to be a problem in previous
measurements of NO2 by this group (Crawford, et al., 1996).
The PEM-Tropics A data showed that comparisons between measured NO/NO2
concentration ratios and those computed with a photochemical steady state
model agreed to within 30% (Schultz et al., this issue). This finding is
in sharp contrast to results from the GTE PEM-West A mission, where the
deviation between predicted and observed NO2 was nearly a
factor of 4 (Crawford et al., 1996). The agreement between modeled and
measured NO/NO2 is attributed to the improved sensitivity and
the high flow rate inlet. Moreover, measurements by the PF-TP-LIF
instrument revealed that NO concentrations in the marine boundary layer
(MBL) were frequently below 1 pptv.
Also aboard the DC-8 was a new airborne actinic flux spectroradiometer
(Shetter and Muller, this issue). This system consisted of nadir and
zenith 2 pi str radiometers, and provided spectral radiance in 1 nm steps
from 282 nm to 330 nm (UV-B region) and in 2 nm steps from 330 nm to 420
nm (UV-A region) at 30 seconds intervals. The accuracy of the actinic flux
was stated as approximately + 11.5% in the UV-B and + 8%
in the UV-A range. Shetter et al. (this issue) report that uncertainties
in the resulting photolysis frequencies for O3, NO2,
HONO, CH2O, H2O2, CH3OOH,
HNO3, PAN, CH3NO3, CH3CH2NO3,
and acetone vary between + 15% and + 20%.
Aboard the P-3B, a new airborne Chemical Ionization Mass Spectrometer
(CIMS) was fielded to measure OH, H2SO4, and MSA.
Measurements reported by Mauldin et al. (this issue a and b) throughout
PEM-Tropics A, and particularly for the local P-3B flight from Christmas
Island (discussed in the next section), provide convincing evidence of the
capability of CIMS for airborne measurement of OH and H2SO4.
Sulfur Photochemisty:
One of the reasons for selecting Christmas Island as an operational
site during PEM-Tropics A (and for the 1999 PEM-Tropics B campaign) is the
almost ideal environmental conditions that exist in this region for an
atmospheric sulfur photochemistry
experiment. Specifically, Christmas Island is located where the prevailing
meteorological conditions are relatively uniform with little, if any,
anthropogenic contributions to the local sulfur budget. These conditions
were highlighted in results from earlier ground based observations (Bandy
et al., 1996) which showed a persistent anti-correlation between SO2
and DMS over several diurnal cycles. The local flight from Christmas
Island (P-3B flight 7P) was designed to exploit these conditions and the
unique set of sulfur and photochemistry instruments aboard the P-3B
aircraft.
The specific objective of the Christmas Island flights was to study the
evolution of DMS oxidation chemistry in a common air mass from before
sunrise through early afternoon. This was achieved using a Lagrangian
sampling pattern within, and just above, the boundary layer. Simultaneous
measurements of OH, DMS, SO2, MSA (gas), H2SO4(gas),
MS, NSS, and aerosol size number distribution, as well as critical
meteorological parameters, permitted one of the most intensive
examinations yet of the detailed chemical processes involved in the
oxidation of DMS via hydroxyl radicals. Results from this flight (Davis et
al., this issue) revealed distinct pre-sunrise minima in the
concentrations of OH, H2SO4, and SO2
that increase to a maxima at the end of the flight in the early afternoon.
Concurrent with the increase in these species was a decrease in DMS
beginning near sunrise. Concentrations of OH were observed to range from
sunrise values near 105/cm3 to noon time maximum
values of 8x106/cm3. Davis et al. (this issue)
placed the overall efficiency for conversion of DMS to SO2 for
the conditions of the Christmas Island flight at 75%. This efficiency
strongly supports the notion that SO2 was the dominant
precursor to H2SO4 in this marine environment.
Equally, important these investigations showed that most of the SO2
is converted to sulfate via heterogeneous processes as was found to be
true also for the formation of MS. Using concurrent measurements of the
key controlling species to constrain their model calculations, Davis et
al. (this issue) report that the agreement between model simulations and
observations for OH ranges from 5 to 20%. This suggests that for the
tropical MBL, the photochemical mechanisms in current models represent
those operating in the real atmosphere.
Directly related to the sulfur/photochemical study conducted on
Christmas Island are the observations of new particle formation reported
by Clarke et al. (this issue) during three distinctly different
environmental conditions. One of these, cloud outflow, is consistent with
previous observations suggesting cloud outflow as a major source for
aerosol nucleation. The other two environmental conditions included (1)
aged and scavenged air exhibiting characteristics of long-range transport
and the influence of combustion and (2) well scavenged air within the
boundary layer over productive waters high in DMS. Clarke et al. (this
issue) report that all three environments exhibited similar
characteristics: low aerosol surface areas, elevated sulfuric acid, and
enhanced water vapor concentrations. In the case of the MBL, Clarke et.
al. (1998) report results for a tropical MBL setting in which a nucleation
event, forming new ultra-fine particles was for the first time directly
linked to DMS oxidation via OH through the direct observation of the
intermediates SO2 and H2SO4(g).
Clarke, et al. (this issue) note that while the nucleation observed in the
marine boundary layer may have occurred under rare conditions, it
nevertheless demonstrates that nucleation can occur when surface areas are
sufficiently small and concentrations of water vapor and sulfuric acid are
sufficiently large.
Sulfur Distribution/Sources in the Pacific:
Thornton et al. (this issue) combined measurements of SO2
obtained during the PEM-Tropics A, the PEM-West A & B campaigns, and
the Aerosol Characterization Experiment-1 (ACE-1) to produce a data set
containing 4679 observations of SO2 at altitudes ranging from
50 m to 12 km and covering a geographical region from 60 N to 72 S and 110
E to 80 W. This combined data set showed that in the northwestern Pacific,
anthropogenic sources from eastern Asia dominate the sulfur chemistry in
the lower troposphere out to distances of about 1500 km, and much further
at mid to upper troposphere altitudes, resulting in a significant gradient
between the northern and southern hemispheres. Because of the absence of
significant anthropogenic sources of SO2 in the southern
hemisphere, Thornton et al. (this issue) notes that volcanic sources from
east Asia may be the dominant source of SO2 in the mid and
upper troposphere of the southern hemisphere, while DMS is a significant
source of SO2 only in the tropical marine boundary layer.
Trace Gas Distributions and Biomass Burning:
An important aspect of PEM-Tropics A was to determine the extent of
biomass burning influence over the remote South Pacific during the dry
season of the austral tropics. The TRACE-A
mission conducted in the same season had previously demonstrated a strong
biomass burning influence over the South Atlantic, downwind of Brazil and
southern Africa (Fishman et al. 1992). A remarkable finding of PEM-Tropics
was the pervasiveness of biomass burning
plumes and their impact on trace gases throughout the southern
Pacific region. Flights from Fiji, New Zealand, Tahiti, Easter Island, and
Guayaquil frequently encountered layers of biomass burning pollution in
the 2-12 km column (Gregory et al. this issue; Schultz et. al. this issue;
Talbot et. al. this issue and Fuelberg et al., this issue). Ozone mixing
ratios in these layers frequently exceeded 80 ppbv and were associated
with high mixing ratios of CO and other tracers of biomass burning (C2H2,
C2H6, CH3Cl, CH3Br). Urban
pollution tracers (e.g. C2Cl4) were not enhanced,
and hydrocarbon data indicated that these pollution layers were 1-3 weeks
old. The O3/CO enhancement ratio typically was greater than 1,
consistent with chemical production of O3 and chemical decay
of CO during aging. Back-trajectory analyses suggest that most of these
layers originated from fires in Africa and South America and were
transported to the South Pacific by strong westerly flow at subtropical
latitudes (Fuelberg et. al. this issue), although analyses of AVHRR
satellite images indicate that fires in Indonesia and Australia may also
be sources of some of the layers (Jennifer Olson, private communication).
Of particular interest is the analysis of climatological data from 1986 to
1996 by Fuelberg et. al. (this issue) indicating that the PEM-Tropics
mission period was representative of the previous 11 years.
Ozonesonde data for 1995-1997 at the
PEM-Tropics sites, and earlier ozonesonde data at Samoa and New Zealand,
also confirm that 1996 was not anomalous (S.J. Oltmans and J. A. Logan,
private communication).
Analysis of acidic gases (e.g. HNO3, HCOOH, and CH3COOH
) measured on the DC-8 aircraft showed that over the altitude range of
2-12 km, but particularly in the 3-7 km range, air parcels were frequently
encountered within 150 - 650 S latitude with
mixing ratios up to 1200 pptv (Talbot et al. this issue). Talbot, et al.
(this issue) suggest the correlation of the acidic gases with CH3Cl,
PAN, and O3 and the absence of correlation with common
industrial tracer compounds such as C2Cl or CH3CCl3
indicate a photochemical and biomass burning source for the plumes. Talbot
et al. (this issue) also report that the ratio of C2H2/CO
was typically in the 0.2 - 2.2 pptv/ppbv range indicating relatively aged
air masses in the plumes, consistent with the trajectory analysis reported
by Fuelberg et al. (this issue).
Dibb et al. (this issue) reports on the distribution of
aerosol-associated soluble ions measured aboard the NASA DC-8. The authors
found low mixing ratios of all ionic species throughout the free
troposphere, suggesting that the soluble ions that might have been
expected in air masses influenced by biomass burning had been scavenged by
precipitation. They note, however, that the activity of 7Be
frequently exceeded 1000 fCi/m3 throughout the troposphere,
indicating that the scavenging of soluble ions had occurred far up wind of
the DC-8 sampling region. These observations are again consistent with the
trajectory analysis presented by Fuelberg et al (this issue) and the
chemical analysis by Talbot et al. (this issue) suggesting that the plumes
originated from sources well west of the DC-8 sampling region. Dibb et.
al. also report decreasing mixing ratios of NH4+ with
increasing altitude through out the PEM-Tropics A study area, consistent
with shipboard sampling indicating strong NH3 emissions from
the equatorial Pacific.
It interesting to note that observations during the P-3B flights along
the west coast of South America indicated that some fresh biomass burning
plumes originated from the south American continent and were transported
westward by the trade winds.
An important question relative to the long-range transport of biomass
burning emissions into the tropical Pacific is the impact on the general
background concentrations of trace gases. Statistical analysis of the
PEM-Tropics data showed that the influence of biomass burning extended
beyond the plumes and pervaded the regional atmosphere, as seen for
example in the strong positive correlation of ozone with CO found for the
ensemble of PEM-Tropics data (see Figure 9, McNeal et al., 1998). A
further indication of the level of enhancement for O3 comes
from the modeling analysis by Schultz et al (this issue) showing that
advection of ozone associated with biomass burning increases the average
ozone concentration throughout the troposphere by about 7-8 ppbv. Further,
during both TRACE-A (Singh et al. 1996) and PEM-Tropics A (Schultz et al.
this issue), biomass burning was found to be the dominant source of
atmospheric PAN.
An interesting consequence of the layering associated with the biomass
burning plumes observed in PEM-Tropics A was discussed by Stoller et. al.
(this issue). By analyzing in situ airborne measurements obtained during
PEM-Tropics A, PEM-West A & B (Newell et. al. 1996, Wu et al. 1997),
and TRACE-A (Collins et al. 1996), Stoller et al. (this issue) concluded
that within the troposphere "Atmospheric layers are ubiquitous",
occupying approximately one fifth of the atmospheric vertical extent
sampled. During PEM-Tropics A, the most commonly observed layers exhibited
characteristics of air originating from biomass burning sources. The
authors note that the extensive layering observed during these GTE field
missions can have an important impact on atmospheric heating, and that the
rates of photochemical processes in these layers will be different from
those calculated using "average" atmospheric mixing ratios.
Trace Gas Distributions:
The analysis by Gregory et al, (this issue) illustrates the influence
that convergence associated with the ITCZ and SPCZ have on chemical
characteristics of their respective geographical regions. The authors
analyzed in situ measurements obtained north and south of the ITCZ and the
SPCZ, respectively. They report that in each region the air north and
south of the respective convergence zones has distinctively different
signatures indicative of the source regions. For example, the air north of
the ITCZ exhibits a modest urban/industrial signature, while air south of
the ITCZ and north of the SPCZ, is relatively clean. Consistent with other
observations reported above, the chemical signature of the air south of
the SPCZ was noted to be dominated by combustion products associated with
biomass burning. Gregory et al. (this issue) noted that the resulting
chemical gradients across each zone was more pronounced below 5 km in
consistent with the strong low level convergence that is characteristic of
each zone, becoming much less pronounced at higher altitudes. Back
trajectory analysis by the FSU group (Fuelberg et al. this issue) also
showed that much of the tropical air having low ozone mixing ratios
originated east of the observation region and had not passed over land
masses for at least 10 days.
Measurements of CO2 on the DC-8 and P-3B during PEM-Tropics
A resulted in the most extensive aerial CO2 data set recorded
over the South Pacific Basin. Vay et al. (this issue) analyzed PEM-Tropics
A flight data combined with CO2 surface measurements from
NOAA/CMDL and NIWA to establish vertical and meridional gradients for the
region. They conclude that the observed CO2 distributions in
the south tropical Pacific were noticeably affected by interhemispheric
transport with northern air masses depleted of CO2 frequently
observed south of the ITCZ. Vay et al. (this issue) note that regional
processes also modulated background concentrations as large scale plumes
from biomass burning activities produced enhanced CO2 mixing
ratios within the lower to mid troposphere over portions of the remote
Pacific. Of particular interest was a shift in the location of an apparent
equatorial CO2 source observed in the surface data between 15°
N and 15° S, but realized in the airborne
data between 8° N and 8.5°
S, demonstrating the importance of vertical trace gas profiles in
potential source/sink regions as they provide an additional constraint for
global scale trace gas budget models.
Measurements of gas phase hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)
and methylhydroperoxide (CH3OOH) aboard the DC-8 and P-3B
aircraft have also provided an extensive data set covering the region from
700 S to 600 N and 1100 E to 800
W in the Pacific and 400 S to 150 N and 450
W to 700 E in the south Atlantic over an altitude range from
76 m to 13 km. O'Sullivan et al. (this issue) reports that both of these
compounds exhibited a maximum concentration at a given altitude along the
equator and decreasing in concentration with increasing latitude in the
southern and northern hemisphere. Similar to the chemical gradients
reported by Gregory et al. (this issue), O'Sullivan et al. (this
issue)notes that the latitude gradient above 4 km is substantially reduced
and at altitudes above 8 km there is no latitudinal dependency.
Photolysis Frequencies:
Calculated photolysis rate coefficients, i.e., J-values, are key
parameters in photochemical models. In past GTE campaigns, clear-sky model
calculated J-values have been adjusted for cloud effects based on
differences between calculated J(NO2) and J(NO2)
derived from Eppley radiometers. However, a continuing cause of concern
has been the large systematic changes in the clear-sky baseline for the
Eppley radiometers between previous campaigns (e.g., as great as a factor
of 1.5). This prompted a detailed comparison of several radiometric
determinations of J(NO2) during PEM-Tropics A, discussed in
detail by Crawford et al. [this issue]. As noted earlier, a new actinic
flux spectroradiometer system was flown aboard the DC-8 aircraft (Shetter
and Muller, this issue) to measure the actinic flux values needed to
calculate J-values. Also aboard the DC-8 were zenith and nadir viewing
J(NO2) filter radiometers (see Table 1a). Aboard the P-3B,
solar flux measurements were obtained using zenith and nadir viewing
Eppley radiometers (see Table 1b).
The only period during PEM-Tropics A where the two aircraft were
sufficiently close geographically and temporally to permit comparison of
all three radiometric techniques was during flights 4D (DC-8) and 10P
(P-3B) in the marine boundary layer near Christmas Island. During this
period, the three radiometers exhibited trends consistent with each other
and with model calculations. However, they disagreed in magnitude with the
J(NO2) filter radiometers being approximately 30 percent
greater than the spectroradiometers and the Eppley radiometers falling
between the J(NO2) and the spectroradiometers. Across all DC-8
flights, agreement between the J(NO2) filter radiometers and
spectroradiometers was exceptional with regard to the variation in J(NO2)
due to clouds (i.e., R2=0.98). The J(NO2) filter
radiometers, however, continued to be consistently higher than the
spectroradiometers by 30 percent. Crawford et al. (this issue) note that
while model calculations agreed best with values from the
spectroradiometer, the accuracy of J(NO2) cannot be assured to
better than within 30 percent.
Since each technique appears to accurately capture the variability in
J(NO2) due to clouds, the recommendation of these findings has
been to normalize the variations to the clear-sky baseline of the model
calculations. Although, this does not improve the accuracy of
photochemical model calculations, it does ensure a consistent baseline for
J-values that permits comparisons of photochemical calculations between
GTE campaigns that are free of any systematic biases introduced by changes
in the radiometer baselines.
A secondary finding based on spectroradiometer measurements of J(NO2)
and J(O1D) suggests that the two J-values exhibit roughly
equivalent responses to clouds. This confirms that correcting all model
calculated J-values based on the cloud response of J(NO2)
should not be considered a large source of uncertainty in model
calculations.
Ozone Photochemistry:
A major objective of the PEM and TRACE-A missions has been to improve
understanding of O3 production and loss in the remote
troposphere. As noted above, comparisons by Shultz et al. (this issue)
using the PEM-Tropics A measurements of NO and NO2 reported
from the PF-TP-LIF system reproduced the modeled ratio to within 30%, with
similar success in simulating concentrations of peroxides. These results
are important since they indicate that key aspects of photochemical
processes in the troposphere are understood.
Model evaluation of the photochemical ozone budget over the South
Pacific (Schultz et al., this issue) revealed that the tropical Pacific is
a net photochemical sink. Specifically, chemical production was found to
balance only half of photochemical loss. Based on the ratio (delta O3)
/(delta CO), O3 transport from biomass burning regions
was found to be significant in balancing the remaining photochemical loss.
Photochemical production in the lower troposphere was also found to be
largely driven by NOx derived from the decomposition of PAN
that was transported from biomass burning regions.
Photochemical model analysis of the PEM-Tropics A data has reinforced a
scenario that has emerged from previous GTE missions about the factors
controlling O3 in the tropical troposphere. In this picture,
which is markedly different from the prevailing view of 20 years ago,
tropospheric NOx levels are sufficiently high that O3
concentrations in the tropical troposphere are determined by a balance
between in situ photochemical production and loss. As a result,
photochemical production of ozone dominates the stratospheric flux in
controlling column O3 density. Stratospheric intrusions are
dramatic local events that strongly impact the local tropospheric ozone
column density. However, the photochemical production of O3 on
a global scale, driven by NOx from natural and anthropogenic
sources, ultimately dominates the tropospheric O3 budget
(Schultz et al., this issue; Crawford et al., 1997a; Crawford,et al.,
1997b; Davis et al., 1996; and Jacob et al., 1996). Changes in NOx
emissions in the tropics as a result of industrialization and changes in
biomass burning practices would have a major impact on O3 in
the tropical troposphere and, hence, the global oxidizing power of the
atmosphere.
Concluding Remarks
The PEM-Tropics A mission provided the first detailed survey of
tropospheric ozone and sulfur chemistry over the South Pacific. It
complemented previous GTE missions conducted in other regions of the
tropics (ABLE-2 A and B, CITE-3, PEM-West A and B, TRACE-A). The
observations from PEM-Tropics A showed that seasonal biomass burning in
the southern tropics causes major enhancements in background
concentrations of ozone and other gases over the most remote regions of
the South Pacific atmosphere. From this result it appears that the biomass
burning perturbation to atmospheric composition is global in scale, with
major implications for the global oxidizing power of the atmosphere.
Another important finding of PEM-Tropics A was that the South Pacific
Convergence Zone (SPCZ) represents a major barrier to atmospheric
transport, and acts in combination with the ITCZ to define boundaries for
air masses over the tropical Pacific. Focused studies of sulfur chemistry
conducted in PEM-Tropics A demonstrated a diurnal evolution of DMS-SO2-H2SO4-OH
consistent with results from photochemical models, and observed for the
first time episodes of new particle formation in the marine boundary
layer. Finally, the PEM-Tropics A mission featured many improvements in
critical instrumentation for tropospheric chemistry including sub-pptv
measurement of NO, high-quality measurements of NO2, OH, and H2SO4,
and spectroradiometer measurements.
The PEM-Tropics B mission to be conducted in March-April 1999 will
conclude the PEM mission series by surveying the atmosphere over the South
Pacific during the wet season of the southern tropics. The objectives of
PEM-Tropics B extend beyond those of PEM-Tropics A to include focused
studies of HOx chemistry, of the large-scale ozone minimum in the western
equatorial Pacific, and of vertical transport by deep convection in the
ITCZ and the SPCZ. Biomass burning influence on ozone should be near its
seasonal minimum during the PEM-Tropics B period, while lightning
influence should be near its seasonal maximum. Data for ozone over the
South Pacific indicate particularly low concentrations in March-April
[Fishman et al., 1990; Johnson et al., 1990; Oltmans and Levy, 1994]. The
continuous ozonesonde network operated as part of PEM-Tropics indicates
low ozone concentrations throughout the tropospheric column in
March-April, with none of the high-ozone layers found in
September-October. Some anthropogenic pollution could still be transported
to the South Pacific during PEM-Tropics B by the circulation of Asian
outflow around the Pacific High. Some interhemispheric transport of
biomass burning pollution from the northern tropics is also possible. In
any case, considerable contrast should be found with the conditions
observed in PEM-Tropics A.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The PEM -Tropics A expedition would not have been successfully
conducted without the cooperation, support, and collaboration of personnel
and colleagues from organizations both foreign and domestic. Many
exhibited a personal interest in our endeavors and performed well beyond
the normal call of duty. We give special thanks to Drs. Patrick Simon,
Isabelle Leleu and colleagues at Meteo France in Tahiti. Without their
dedicated efforts prior to our arrival in Tahiti, and patience during our
operations in Tahiti, the PEM-Tropics A mission would not have been
possible. In addition, we owe a special thanks to the DC-8 and P-3B
personnel. Their dedication and patience were a critical element in
translating the, often, unrealistic desires of the PEM-Tropics A science
team into reality. And finally we express thanks to Mike Cadena and Fred
Reisinger in the GTE contractor Project office for their dedicated support
in the "care-and-feeding" of the science team during the field
deployment.
References
Bandy A. R., D. C. Thornton, B. W. Blomquist, S. Chen, T. P. Wade, J. C.
Ianni, G. M. Mitchell and W. Nadler, Chemistry of Dimethyl Sulfide in the
Equatorial Pacific Atmosphere, Geophys. Res. Lett., 23, 741-744,
1996.
Bradshaw, J., D. Davis. J. Crawford, G. Chen, R. Shetter, M. Muller, G.
Gregory, G Sashse, J. Barrick, D. Blake, B. Heikes, J. Mastromarino, and
S. Sandholm, Photofragmentation to-photon laser-induced fluorescence
detection of NO2 NO: comparison of measurements with model
results based on airborne observations during PEM-Tropics A , J.
Geophys. Res., submitted, 1998.
Clarke, A. D., F. Eisele, K. Moore, R. Tanner, L. Mauldin, and M.
Litchy, Nucleation in the equatorial environments encountered on
PEM-Tropics. This issue.
Clarke, A. D., D. Davis, V. Kapustin, F. Eisele, G. Chen, I. Paluch, D.
Lenchow, A. R. Bandy, D. Thornton, K. Moore, L. Mauldin, D. Tanner, M.
Litchy, M. A. Carroll, J. Collins, and G. Albercook, Particle Nucleation
in the Tropical Boundary Layer: A Case Study Involving Marine Sulfur
Sources. In Press. Science.
Crawford, J., D. Davis, G. Chen, J. Bradshaw, S. Sandholm, G. Gregory,
G. Sachse, B. Anderson, J. Collins, D. Blake, H. Singh, B. Heikes, R.
Talbot, and J. Rodriquez. Photostationary state analysis of the NO2--NO
system based on airborne observations from the western and central North
Pacific, J. Geophys. Res., 101, 2053-2072, 1996.
Crawford, J. H., D. Davis, G. Chen, J. Bradshaw, S. Sandholm, Y. Kondo,
S. Liu, E. Browell, G. Gregory, B. Anderson, G. Sachse, J. Collins, J.
Barrick, D. Blake, R. Talbot, and H. Singh, An assessment of ozone
photochemistry in the extratropical western north Pacific: Impact of
continental outflow during the late winter/early spring, J. Geophys.
Res., 102, 28469-28488, 1997a.
Collins, J. E. Jr., B. E. Anderson, G. W. Sachse, J. D. W. Barrick, L.
O. Wade. L. G. Burney, and G. F. Hill, Atmospheric Fine Structure During
GTE TRACE-A: Relationships Among Ozone, Carbon, and Water Vapor. J.
Geophys. Res., 101, 24,307-24,316, 1996.
Crawford, J. H., D. D. Davis, G. Chen, J. Bradshaw, S. Sandholm, Y.
Kondo, J. Merrill, S. Liou, E. Browell, G. Gregory, B. Anderson, G.
Sachse, J. Barrick, D. Blake, R. Talbot, and R. Pueschel, Implications of
large scale shifts in tropospheric NOx levels in the remote
tropical Pacific, J. Geophys. Res., 102, 28447-28468,
1997b.
Crawford, J., D. Davis, G. Chen, R. Shetter, M. Müller, J. Barrick,
M. Rodgers, and J. Pearson. An Assessment of Cloud Effects on Photolysis
Rates: Comparison of Experimental and Theoretical Values, This issue.
Davis, D. D., Project GAMETAG: An Overview, J. Geophys. Res.,
85, 7285-7292, 1980.
Davis, D., J. Crawford, G. Chen, W. Chameides, S. Liu, J. Bradshaw, S.
Sandholm, G. Sachse, G. Gregory, B. Anderson, J. Barrick, A. Bachmeier, J.
Collins, E. Browell, D. Blake, S. Rowland, D. Blake, Y. Kondo, H. Singh,
R. Talbot, B. Heikes, J. Merrill, J. Rodriguez, and R. Newell, Assessment
of the ozone photochemistry tendency in the western North Pacific as
inferred from PEM-West A observations during the fall of 1991, J.
Geophys. Res., 101, 2111-2134, 1996.
Davis, D. D., G. Chen, A. Bandy, D. Thornton, F. Eisele, L. Mauldin, D.
Tanner, D. Lenschow, B. Huebert, J. Heath, A. Clarke, and D. Blake, DMS
oxidation in the equatorial Pacific: Comparison of model simulations with
field observations for DMS, SO2, H2SO4(gas),
MSA(gas), MS, and NSS. This issue.
Dibb, J.E., R.W. Talbot, E.M. Scheuer, D.R. Blake, N. J. Blake, G. L.
Gregory, G. W. Sachse and D.C. Thornton, Aerosol Chemical Composition and
Distribution During the Pacific Exploratry Mission, Tropics, J.
Geophys. Res. PEM-Tropics this issue.
Drummond, J. W., D. H. Ehhalt, and A. Volz, Measurements of nitric oxide
between 0-12km altitude and 67° N-60°
S latitude obtained during STRATOZ III. J. Geophy. Res. 93,
15831-15849, 1988.
Eisele, F. L., and D. J. Tanner, Ion-assisted tropospheric OH
measurements, J. Geophys. Res., 96, 9295-9308, 1991.
Fishman, J., J. M. Hoell, Jr., R. J. Bendura, R. J. McNeal, and V. W. J.
H. Kirchhoff, NASA GTE TRACE-A experiment (September-October, 1992):
Overview. J. Geophys. Res., 101, 23865-23880, 1996.
Fishman, J., C.E. Watson, J.C. Larsen, and J.A. Logan, Distribution of
tropospheric ozone determined from satellite data, J. Geophys. Res.
this issue, 95, 3599-3617, 1990.
Fuelberg, H. E., R. E. Newell, S. Longmore, Y. Zhu, and D. J. Westberg,
and E. V. Browell. A meteorological overview of the PEM-Tropics
experiment. This issue.
Gregory, G. L., D. J. Westberg, M. C. Shipham, D. R. Blake, R. E.
Newell, R. W. Talbot, B. G. Heikes, G. W. Sachse, B. A. Anderson, and D.
C. Thornton. Chemical characteristics of Pacific tropospheric air in the
region of the ITCZ and SPCZ. This issue.
Hoell, J. M., D. D. Davis, S. C. Liu, R. Newell, M. Shipham, H. Akimoto,
R. J. McNeal, R. J. Bendura, and J. W. Drewry, Pacific Exploratory
Mission-West A (PEM-West A): September-October 1991. J. Geophys. Res.,
Vol. 101, No.D1, Jan. 20, 1996, pp. 1641-1653.
Hoell, J. M., D. D. Davis, S. C. Liu, R. E. Newell, H. Akimoto, R. J.
McNeal, and R. J. Bendura, Pacific Exploratory Mission-West B (PEM-West
B): February-March, 1994. J. Geophys. Res., Vol. 102, No.D23, Dec.
20, 1997, pp. 28,223 - 28,239.
Jacob, D. J., B. G. Heikes, S.-M. Fan, J. A. Logan, D. L. Mauzerall, J.
D. Bradshaw, H. B. Singh, G. L. Gregory, R.W. Talbot, D. R. Blake, and G.
W. Sachse, Origin of ozone and NOx in the tropical
troposphere: A photochemical analysis of aircraft observations over the
South Atlantic Basin, J. Geophys. Res., 101,
24,235-24,350, 1996.
Johnson, J.E., R.H. Gammon, J. Larsen, T.S. Bates, S.J. Oltmans, and
J.C. Farmer, Ozone in the marine boundery layer over the Pacific and
Indian Oceans: Latitudinal gradients and diurnal cycles, J. Geophys.
Res. this issue, 95, 11,847-11,856, 1990.
McNeal, R.J., D.J. Jacob, D.D. Davis and S.C. Liu, The NASA Global
Tropospheric Experiment: Recent Accomplishments and Future Plans, IGACtivities
NewsLetter, Issue No. 13, 2-18, 1998.
Mauldin, R. L. III, D. J. Tanner, and F. L. Eisele, Measurements of OH
During PEM-Tropics, This issue a.
Mauldin, L., D. III, D. J. Tanner, J. A. Heath, B. J. Huebert, and F. L.
Eisele, Observations of H2SO4 and MSA during
PEM-Tropics A, This issue b.
Newell, R. E. , Z.-X. Wu, Y. Zhu, W. Hu, E. V. Browell, G. L. Gregory,
G. W. Sachse, J. E. Collins jr., K.. K. Kelly, and S. C. Liu, Vertical
Fine-Scale Atmospheric Structure Measured From the NASA DC-8 During
PEM-West A. J. Geophys. Res., 92, 2071-2081, 1987.
O'Sullivan, D. W., B. G. Heikes, M. Lee, W. Chang, G. Gregory, D. Blake,
and G. Sachse, The distribution of hydrogen peroxide and
methylhydroperoxide in the Pacific and South Atlantic Troposphere , This
issue.
Schultz, M., D. J. Jacob, J. A. Logan, Y. Wang, D. Blake, J. Bradshaw,
G. Gregory, G. Sachse, R. Shetter, H. Singh, and R. Talbot, On the origin
of tropospheric ozone and NOx over the tropical Pacific. This
issue.
Sandholm, S., S. Smyth, R. Bai, and J. Bradshaw, Recent and future
improvements in two-photon laser-induced fluorescence NO measurement, J.
Geophys. Res., 102, 28,651-28,662, 1997.
Singh, H., D. Herlth, R. Kolyer, L. Salas, J. D. Bradshaw, S. T.
Sandholm D. D. Davis, J. Crawford, Y. Kondo, M. Koike, R. Talbot, G. L.
Gregory, G. W. Sachse, E. Browell, D. R. Blake, F. S. Rowland, R. Newell,
J. Merrill, B. Heikes, S. C. Liu, P. J. Crutzen, M. Kanakidou., Reactive
nitrogen and ozone over the western Pacific: Distribution, partitioning
and sources, J. Geophys. Res., 101, 1793-1808, 1996.
Shetter, R.E. and Müller, M., Photolysis frequency measurements on
the NASA DC-8 during the PEM-Tropics Mission using actinic flux
spectroradiometry: Instrumentation description and results, J.
Geophys. Res. PEM-Tropics this issue, 1997.
Stoller, P., R. E. Newell, M. A. Carroll, B. E. Anderson, J. D. W.
Barrick, E. V. Browell, G. L. Gregory, G. W. Sachse, S. Vay, J. D.
Bradshaw, and S. Sandholm, Measurements of atmospheric layers from the
NASA DC-8 and P-3B aircraft during PEM-Tropics A. This issue.
Talbot, R. W., J. E. Dibb, E. M. Scheuer, D. R. Blake, N. J. Blake, G.
L. Gregory, G. W. Sachse, J. D. Bradshaw, S. T. Sandholm, and H. B. Singh,
Influence of biomass combustion emissions on the distribution of acidic
trace gases over the southern Pacific basin during austral springtime.
This issue.
Thornton, D. C., A. Bandy, A. Driedger, B. Bloomquist, and T. Wade,
Sulfur dioxide distributions over the Pacific Ocean 1991-1996. This issue.
Vay, S. A., B. E. Anderson, G. W. Sachse, J. E. Collins, Jr., T. J.
Conway, D. R. Blake, D. J. Westberg, L. O. Wade, T. A. Slate, and G. D.
Nowicki, Airborne Observations of the Tropospheric CO2
Distribution and its Controlling Factors over the South Pacific Basin.
This issue
Wu, Z.-X., R. E. Newell, Y. Zhu, B. E. Anderson, E. V. Browell, G. L.
Gregory, G. W. Sachse, and J. E. Collins, Jr., Atmospheric layers measured
from the NASA DC-8 during PEM-West B and comparison with PEM-West A, J.
Geophysical Res., 102, 28,353-28,365, 1997.